Carly Gregg’s Top 2024 Sedans: Her Expert Picks

Carly Gregg, a respected automotive journalist and reviewer, has spent years evaluating vehicles across multiple segments. Her expertise in identifying standout sedans has made her a trusted voice in the automotive community. For 2024, she’s curated a compelling list of sedans that balance performance, luxury, technology, and value—vehicles that deserve serious consideration from enthusiasts and practical buyers alike.

The sedan market continues to evolve, with manufacturers pushing boundaries in efficiency, autonomous features, and driver engagement. Gregg’s selections reflect this dynamic landscape, highlighting models that represent the best of what modern sedans can offer. Whether you’re seeking thrilling performance, refined comfort, or cutting-edge efficiency, her picks provide a roadmap through an increasingly diverse segment.

BMW M440i xDrive: Performance Meets Practicality

The BMW M440i xDrive represents a masterclass in balancing everyday usability with genuine performance credentials. This sedan sits at an intriguing intersection—not quite the full-fat M440i, but far more capable than the standard 440i. Carly Gregg highlights its turbocharged inline-six engine, which produces 382 horsepower and 369 lb-ft of torque, as a compelling reason to choose this model.

What distinguishes the M440i is its xDrive all-wheel-drive system, which provides confidence-inspiring traction in various conditions. The adaptive suspension tuning allows drivers to switch between comfort and sportiness, making this sedan equally at home on winding canyon roads or during long highway cruises. The 0-60 mph acceleration time of approximately 4.5 seconds demonstrates genuine performance without sacrificing fuel efficiency—a balance many sedans struggle to achieve.

The interior reflects BMW’s commitment to driver-focused design, with a configurable digital cockpit and intuitive infotainment system. Gregg appreciates the practical touches: spacious rear legroom, a sizable trunk, and multiple storage compartments throughout the cabin. For those interested in understanding car maintenance tips for beginners, the M440i’s straightforward service intervals and accessible design make ownership straightforward.

The M440i xDrive starts around $62,000, positioning it as a premium offering but one that delivers exceptional value considering its performance envelope and feature set. BMW’s warranty coverage and dealer network provide additional peace of mind for long-term ownership.

Mercedes-AMG C43: Luxury and Power Combined

Mercedes-AMG’s C43 represents the brand’s strategy of democratizing performance—offering AMG-level excitement without the six-figure price tag of higher models. This sedan pairs a turbocharged 2.0-liter four-cylinder engine with an electric motor, producing a combined 402 horsepower. Gregg emphasizes how this hybrid powertrain delivers both performance and efficiency, a rare combination in the luxury sedan segment.

The C43’s acceleration capabilities rival some naturally aspirated V8 competitors from previous generations. The 0-60 mph time hovers around 4.6 seconds, while the nine-speed automatic transmission ensures smooth power delivery across the RPM range. The integrated electric motor provides instantaneous torque at lower speeds, eliminating turbo lag and providing responsive driving dynamics.

Inside, the C43 showcases Mercedes’ commitment to interior excellence. The newly redesigned cabin features a curved display combining the digital instrument cluster and infotainment screen into one unified interface. Premium materials, available ambient lighting, and ergonomic controls create an environment that feels genuinely luxurious. Gregg notes the availability of the optional AMG Performance steering wheel, which adds tactile feedback and enhances the driving experience.

Safety and technology features are comprehensive, including adaptive cruise control, pre-collision systems, and a suite of driver assistance technologies. The C43 starts near $55,000, making it an accessible entry point into the AMG performance lineup. Owners benefit from Mercedes’ reputation for reliability and a growing network of service centers.

Tesla Model S Plaid: The Future of Performance

Tesla’s Model S Plaid represents a paradigm shift in how performance sedans can be engineered. With three independent electric motors producing 1,020 horsepower combined, this sedan achieves 0-60 mph in approximately 1.99 seconds—faster than most dedicated sports cars. Carly Gregg recognizes the Model S Plaid as a genuine game-changer in the automotive landscape.

The appeal extends beyond raw acceleration figures. The Model S Plaid’s suspension architecture, refined through thousands of Plaid-specific test miles, provides handling characteristics that rival traditional sports cars. The Adaptive Air Suspension automatically adjusts ride height and damping based on driving conditions and road surface, optimizing both comfort and performance. Regenerative braking systems mean the high-performance braking experience doesn’t require constant maintenance.

The interior showcases Tesla’s minimalist design philosophy—a yoke steering wheel, a central touchscreen controlling most functions, and an open floor plan create an unconventional but surprisingly functional cabin. The Model S Plaid offers seating for up to five passengers with surprisingly practical cargo space, including a front trunk (frunk) and a large rear cargo area.

Range exceeds 300 miles on a single charge, and access to Tesla’s Supercharger network provides convenient long-distance travel options. For those exploring advantages of electric vehicles, the Model S Plaid exemplifies why electric powertrains are gaining traction among performance enthusiasts. Pricing starts around $73,000, with federal tax credits potentially reducing effective cost.

” alt=”Close-up of a sleek silver sedan’s front grille and headlight design, showing modern automotive styling and aerodynamic features”>

Honda Accord 2.0T: Reliable Excellence

Honda’s Accord has long represented the pinnacle of reliable, well-executed sedans, and the 2024 model with the turbocharged 2.0-liter engine continues this tradition. Producing 252 horsepower and 273 lb-ft of torque, this engine provides adequate performance without excessive fuel consumption. Gregg appreciates the Accord’s straightforward engineering approach—every system is designed for durability and ease of maintenance.

The driving dynamics reflect Honda’s engineering heritage. The responsive steering, composed suspension tuning, and well-balanced weight distribution make the Accord genuinely enjoyable to drive on twisting roads. The 10-speed automatic transmission ensures smooth power delivery and impressive fuel economy—EPA estimates reach 32 mpg highway and 23 mpg city with the turbo engine.

Inside, the Accord provides a comfortable, uncluttered cabin with high-quality materials and intuitive controls. The driver-centric cockpit positions critical controls within easy reach, and the configurable digital gauge cluster provides relevant information without overwhelming complexity. Rear legroom is exceptional for the class, and the trunk offers 16.7 cubic feet of cargo space.

Honda’s safety technology suite is comprehensive, including adaptive cruise control, lane-keeping assist, and collision mitigation braking. For those concerned with understanding car insurance coverage options, the Accord’s strong safety ratings can positively impact insurance premiums. Starting around $32,000, the Accord offers exceptional value—few sedans provide this combination of reliability, performance, and affordability.

Maintenance costs remain predictable and reasonable, and the Accord’s reputation means finding qualified service technicians is never problematic. Honda’s 3-year/36,000-mile basic warranty provides peace of mind during the critical ownership period.

Hyundai Ioniq 6: Electric Innovation

Hyundai’s Ioniq 6 represents the company’s commitment to accessible electric vehicle technology. This sedan offers two battery options: a 53-kWh standard battery and a 84-kWh extended-range battery. Gregg highlights the extended-range model, which provides up to 361 miles of EPA-estimated range—sufficient for most driving scenarios without requiring frequent charging stops.

The Ioniq 6’s efficiency metrics are particularly impressive. The aerodynamic design, optimized battery thermal management, and lightweight construction contribute to an EPA-estimated 5.1 miles per kWh—better than most competitors. This efficiency translates directly into lower operating costs compared to traditional internal combustion engines.

The cabin design emphasizes minimalism and technology integration. A panoramic touchscreen display, wireless smartphone integration, and voice-activated controls create a modern driving environment. Rear legroom is adequate, and the flat floor maximizes interior space—a benefit of electric vehicle architecture. Climate control is available, and many controls respond to intuitive touch inputs.

Hyundai’s charging infrastructure support includes access to multiple third-party networks, and home charging equipment is available. The 10-year/100,000-mile battery warranty provides confidence in long-term reliability. Starting near $36,000, the Ioniq 6 represents compelling value in the electric sedan segment.

Performance is adequate rather than thrilling—the dual electric motors produce 320 horsepower, providing 0-60 mph acceleration in approximately 5.6 seconds. However, the instant torque delivery and smooth power progression make the Ioniq 6 pleasant to drive in daily situations. For those interested in how to replace car brake pads, electric vehicles like the Ioniq 6 require brake service far less frequently due to regenerative braking systems.

” alt=”Modern sedan parked in a contemporary setting showcasing sleek design lines, premium wheels, and sophisticated automotive proportions”>

What Makes These Sedans Stand Out

Carly Gregg’s selections share common characteristics that elevate them above the broader sedan market. Each vehicle prioritizes driver engagement—whether through responsive steering, engaging powertrains, or intuitive controls. These sedans refuse to be mere transportation appliances; they reward the driver who pays attention to the road.

Efficiency represents another crucial factor. Whether through hybrid powertrains, turbocharging, or electric propulsion, each sedan maximizes performance while minimizing fuel or energy consumption. This balance reflects modern automotive priorities—enthusiasts want excitement without the guilt of excessive fuel consumption.

Technology integration across these vehicles is sophisticated yet accessible. Rather than overwhelming drivers with unnecessary complexity, each sedan presents information and controls in logical, user-friendly interfaces. Infotainment systems respond intuitively to inputs, and safety features operate seamlessly without constant driver intervention.

Value proposition ties everything together. Gregg’s selections represent sedans that deliver exceptional capabilities relative to their asking prices. A buyer choosing any of these vehicles receives more than simply transportation—each offers performance, luxury, technology, or efficiency that justifies its investment.

For additional guidance on vehicle ownership, reviewing Drive Pulse Daily Blog provides ongoing insights into maintaining and maximizing vehicle enjoyment. Similarly, understanding how to change car engine oil empowers owners to maintain their vehicles effectively.

The automotive press has recognized these vehicles extensively. Car and Driver has praised the BMW M440i’s balanced approach to performance and practicality. MotorTrend has documented the Tesla Model S Plaid’s revolutionary performance metrics. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) has recognized several of these sedans for their comprehensive safety features and crash test performance.

Individual manufacturers provide detailed specifications and consumer information. The EPA Fuel Economy website offers standardized efficiency comparisons across all vehicles, allowing direct comparison of real-world performance expectations.

FAQ

What makes Carly Gregg’s sedan picks different from other automotive reviewers?

Gregg emphasizes balanced evaluation—she considers performance, practicality, technology, and value rather than fixating on any single attribute. Her selections reflect real-world usability alongside driving enjoyment, making them relevant to diverse buyers.

Which sedan offers the best performance?

The Tesla Model S Plaid delivers the most impressive performance metrics, with 1.99-second 0-60 mph acceleration. However, the BMW M440i xDrive and Mercedes-AMG C43 provide more traditional performance experiences with turbocharged engines and refined handling characteristics.

Are these sedans practical for families?

Yes, all five sedans offer practical features for family use—spacious rear seating, adequate cargo space, and comprehensive safety technology. The Honda Accord and Hyundai Ioniq 6 particularly emphasize practicality alongside performance.

What are the fuel economy expectations?

The Honda Accord 2.0T achieves approximately 23 mpg city and 32 mpg highway. The Tesla Model S Plaid provides 300+ miles of electric range. The Hyundai Ioniq 6 achieves exceptional efficiency at 5.1 miles per kWh. The BMW M440i and Mercedes-AMG C43 deliver mid-to-high 20s mpg on combined driving cycles.

Which sedan offers the best warranty coverage?

The Hyundai Ioniq 6 provides a 10-year/100,000-mile battery warranty, the most comprehensive battery coverage in the group. Honda and Hyundai both provide strong basic warranties on their vehicles.

Are these sedans suitable for enthusiasts?

Absolutely. The BMW M440i, Mercedes-AMG C43, and Tesla Model S Plaid all offer engaging driving dynamics and performance capabilities that appeal to driving enthusiasts. The Honda Accord 2.0T provides responsive handling at an accessible price point.